In Sid Meier's Pirates! Gold Plus, players navigate the treacherous waters of the 17th century as they engage in ship battles, treasure hunting, and sword fighting. The game features a mix of exploration, combat, and strategy, allowing players to build their reputation as a feared pirate or a noble privateer.

The storyline of Sid Meier's Pirates! Gold Plus revolves around the player's quest for fame and fortune in the Caribbean, where they can choose to pursue various objectives, including rescuing kidnapped governors' daughters or plundering enemy ships.

Sid Meier's Pirates! Gold Plus stands out with its enhanced graphics and sound, improved sword-fighting mechanics, and the inclusion of the original game, providing both nostalgia and a fresh experience for players.